Source: York University Libraries: http://researchguides.library.yorku.ca/c.php?g=679490&p=4790245
Consider the following when reviewing a publication:
- Does the author acknowledge their sources?
- Is the content substantial, appear to be valid and well-researched, and make sense with your background knowledge or other articles' knowledge in the field?
- Is the writing scholarly and professional? Does data appear to support the content in a scholarly manner or is it sensational and attention-getting?
- Is the article listed as peer-reviewed?
- Is the article written for experts in the field or members of the general public?
- Is the article published in a scholarly journal? Check the journal's submissions policies if necessary.
