You can use Ulrich's Periodical Directory Online to verify whether a journal is peer-reviewed/refereed (the epitome of a scholarly publication)
For more info:
"Day 231: Exciting Library Books!" by Anomalily. Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommerical license. http://www.flickr.com/photos/lilymonster/3753280427/
Examples of Evaluation Criteria:
CRAAP Test - click on "Evaluate Information" (by Meriam Library - California State University, Chico)
Evaluate this article:
Yates, Joshua J. "Making Sense of Cosmopolitanism: A Conversation with Kwame Anthony Appiah." Hedgehog Review 11.3 (Fall 2009):42-50
Sample Topic: cosmopolitanism and borges
Research Guides & Subject Guides help to identify relevant article-databases for your topic.
UTOR ID is required to log-in
Examples:
Humanities Abstracts - Ebsco
MLA (Modern Language Association) - Proquest*
Philosopher's Index - Proquest*
Francis - Proquest*
*Proquest resources can be searched simultaneously or individually